
Electron
Microscopy of Tumors of the Peripheral Nerve Sheath
Cyril Fisher, London,
United Kingdom
Tumors of the peripheral nerve are
predominantly those of the nerve sheath but can also include some
peripheral primitive neuroectodermal tumors, gastrointestinal
autonomic nerve tumors, and peripheral neuroblastoma. This presentation
will concern tumors of the peripheral nerve sheath - schwannoma,
neurofibroma, perineurioma, and malignant peripheral nerve sheath
tumor, and their variants.
THE CELLS OF THE NERVE SHEATH
The epineurium is a layer of connective tissue enclosing the other
layers of the nerve. The nerve sheath cells are principally the
Schwann cell and the perineurial cell, both characterized by
cytoplasmic processes.
Schwann cells, the inside layer of the endoneurium, surround the
axon and produce myelin, external lamina and collagen. They have
interdigitating cytoplasmic processes and continuous external
lamina. In myelinated nerves there is one Schwann cell per axon,
and in non-myelinated nerves there are several axon segments within
a single Schwann cell, but with very few layers of schwannian
plasma membrane. The Schwann cell is neural-crest derived and
is positive for S100 protein, Leu7, laminin, and myelin basic
protein, and negative for cytokeratin, epithelial membrane antigen
(EMA), desmin and muscle actins.
Perineurial cells form a few circumferential layers outside the
endoneurium. They are bipolar (rarely tripolar) cells with very
long, thin processes. The perineurial cell differs from a fibroblast
by the presence of external lamina (continuous or interrupted),
pinocytosis, and intercellular junctions. Perineurial cells derive
from the arachnoid, and display positivity for EMA, but not for
cytokeratin, S100 protein or (usually) Leu7, although perineurial-like
cells occasionally show actin positivity. A third cell type has
been identified within the endoneurium as a slender dendritic
spindle cell which displays CD34 positivity, and which appears
to be distinct from Schwann, perineurial or endothelial cells.
It may be analogous to the dermal dendritic fibroblast. CD34
positive cells are found in increased numbers in neurofibromas
and in Antoni B areas of schwannomas, but only in about 15% of
MPNST.
|
 |
|
Pseudomesaxon |
Schwannoma |
BENIGN PERIPHERAL NERVE SHEATH TUMORS
Schwannomas show strong diffuse S100
protein-positivity, and also Leu7. GFAP has been reported in
about a third of schwannomas (more frequently in those in the
GI tract (Daimaru et al, 1988)) and also in 40% of neurofibromas
(Gray et al, 1989). Electron microscopy shows Schwann cells only;
attenuated interdigitating cell processes lie in undulating layers
adjacent to cell body, covered in continuous external lamina 500
Å thick, some of which is also redundant in extracellular
space. The cytoplasm contains microfibrils, lysosomes, mitochondria.
In Antoni B areas, the cells are dispersed in a myxoid stroma,
the cytoplasm has more lysosomes and myelin figures and a fragmented
external lamina, so that these perhaps represent degenerate Antoni
A areas. Long-spacing collagen in seen in the stroma of benign
peripheral nerve sheath tumors and occasionally in malignant ones,
but is not specific.
In cellular schwannoma, the ultrastructure is that of well differentiated
schwann cells but with less interdigitation than in regular schwannoma.
External lamina can be absent when processes are closely apposed.
EM is occasionally useful in the differential with smooth muscle
tumor.
Granular cell schwannoma is the suggested term for granular cell
tumor (previously myoblastoma), because of its S100 positive immunophenotype,
occasional neural connection, and occasional appearance in neurofibromatosis.
EM shows numerous autophagosomes with various lipoid and membranous
inclusions.
Neurofibromas have focal S100 positivity in schwann cells but
less strongly and in fewer cells than in schwannoma . The majority
of neurofibromas are negative for EMA but about 25% show some
positivity in irregular fascicles of cells, as well as around
the edge (residual nerve). Ultrastructurally there is a mixture
of Schwann cells, with or without nerves, perineurial-like cells
and fibroblasts, with intermediate forms between the cell types.
In the plexiform type, the early stage is increased endoneurial
matrix, separating nerve fibres, which are later replaced by Schwann
cells with thick wavy collagen bundles, and scattered small axons.
EM shows Schwann cells, fibroblasts, and perineurial cells.
Perineuriomas are rare, and not all those reported as such are
acceptable. However, they do appear to be monomorphic proliferations
which have the gross morphology (a discrete, circumscribed but
unencapsulated mass) of a tumor rather than hyperplasia. Such
tumors (not to be confused with intraneurial perineurioma or localised
hypertrophic neuropathy, see below) are reported in soft tissues,
more commonly in women and affecting the back or shoulder, as
similar to neurofibroma but more cellular (although hypocellular
examples have been reported). The cases described by Giannini
et al had evidence of deletion of part of chromosome 22(M-bcr
locus at 22q11). Histologically, they are neurofibroma-like,
fibromatosis-like or even meningioma-like variably cellular spindle
cell lesions with whorls or lamellar formations. Myxoid change
is common. Lacking both Schwann cells and S100 immunoreactivity,
this tumor is best recognized ultrastructurally and by EMA positivity,
although this can be faint as the cytoplasmic processes are very
slender. Sclerosing perineurioma is a lesion affecting predominantly
the thumb, fingers and palm, composed of small epithelioid and
spindled cells in cords, trabeculae and whorls in a fibrous stroma.
In addition to EMA positivity, some of these expressed cytokeratin.
|
|
|
Cellular Schwannoma |
Perineuroma |
Localized Hypertrophic Neuropathy (intraneural perineurioma, onion
bulb perineurial cell hyperplasia) affects young adults, males
more than females, and especially the posterior interosseous nerve.
This forms a large cylindrical enlargement a few cms long. Histologically,
in cross section there are sheets of onion bulb-like transections.
EM shows each with a central axon plus schwann cell, surrounded
by layers of cells with curved thin processes, pinocytotic vesicles,
and interrupted external lamina. These are EMA-positive and S100
negative and are regarded as perineurial cells. The spatial relationship
of the three elements has suggested a hyperplastic rather than
neoplastic process, but the recent observation in intraneural
perineuriomas of a clonal abnormality involving loss of 22q11.2
(Emory et al, 1995) has suggested the converse (the NF2 tumor
suppressor gene is localized to 22q11.2-q12). This lesion should
not be confused with extraneural perineurial cell tumor in soft
tissue.
Ossifying Fibromyxoid Tumor This recently recognized entity is
of uncertain nature but there is evidence to suggest that it might
be a schwann cell tumor with low malignant potential. It is a
tumor of adults, commoner in men, occurring in the subcutis or
muscle mostly of the extremities. The tumor has a thick fibrous
capsule from which septa extend in, giving a partially lobulated
pattern. 80% have foci of mature benign lamellar bone within
the capsule and its extensions. The tumor cells are small and
round with vesicular nuclei and ill-defined cytoplasm and cell
margins, arranged in cords or small nests or focally glomus-like.
The stroma is myxoid and focally fibrosed or hyaline, in places
suggesting osteoid formation. Mitotic activity is usually minimal
and there is no necrosis or vascular invasion. Atypical variants
have been described. Some cases recur, and an occasional metastasis
has been reported.
The majority of cells are strongly positive for S 100 protein
and for NSE, and some have GFAP positivity. No reactivity is
detected with HMB45, or with antibodies to cytokeratin, EMA, or
neurofilament. However, in some examples of this tumor a few
cells have desmin and actin positivity. Electron microscopy shows
the tumor cells to have rather short cytoplasmic processes with
occasional cell membrane thickening suggestive of attempted junction
formation but no definite desmosomes. Many cells have a discontinuous,
thick external lamina which is focally reduplicated into the stroma.
There are tangles of cytoplasmic intermediate filaments but no
characteristic myofilaments. Ribosome-lamella complexes have
been described. The tumor differs ultrastructurally from myxoid
chondrosarcoma.
MALIGNANT PERIPHERAL NERVE SHEATH
TUMORS
MPNST has a variety of morphologic patterns - neurofibroma-like,
fibrosarcoma-like with alternating cellular and myxoid zones,
neuroid whorls and subintimal invasion, epithelioid, and with
divergent differentiation. Only 50-70% of MPNST (including the
epithelioid type) are S100 protein positive, often in more differentiated,
loose, wavy areas. S100 immunoreactivity is helpful diagnostically
in tumors of a spindle cell type, but other spindle cell tumors
can be positive, including synovial sarcoma. MPNST with heterologous
elements will contain the corresponding antigens. MPNST lacks
neurofilament, but occasional tumors are NSE positive, and some
express myelin basic protein. Muscle-specific actin or smooth
muscle actin may be seen in many non-muscle tumors including MPNST.
Cytokeratin may be present in scattered cells in the spindle
component, causing a problem with distinction from synovial sarcoma
in some cases. CD34 and bcl2 are variably expressed, but usually
only focally.
Many cases of MPNST, so categorized by a neural connexion and
appropriate histology, show no differentiation at the ultrastructural
level. Electron microscopy of well differentiated MPNST of usual
spindle cell type can show numerous cytoplasmic processes which
interdigitate with those of other cells and occasionally form
junctional complexes. These are of variable shape, size and development.
MPNST can also contain basal lamina; however, this can be detached,
incomplete or undeveloped in poorly differentiated tumors. Long
spacing collagen is also found on occasion.
Correlation between ultrastructure and immunohistochemistry.
Cases with good schwann cell differentiation (interdigitating
cytoplasmic processes, external lamina) have strong S100 positivity
and also Leu7. A spectrum of decreasing morphological resemblance
to schwann cells is demonstrable (Fisher et al), accompanied by
loss of immunohistochemical markers. Hirose et al (1989) have
reported EMA positivity in MPNST with schwannian ultrastructure,
and also cytokeratin (although not necessarily in their EMA +
cases).
Malignant perineurial cell tumor Some poorly differentiated (S100
negative) MPNST are found ultrastructurally to have features of
perineurial cell differentiation. Sporadic cases have been described
(Hirose 1989; Fisher, 1990, ), and a series of 7 cases in adults
was reported in 1998 by Hirose et al, as occasionally necrotic
spindle cell sarcomas with mitoses, which were EMA positive; two
displayed CD34. EM showed perineurial-like bipolar cells with
pinocytosis and fragments of lamina in 3 cases, and cells intermediate
between perineurial and schwann cells in one. Four examples recurred
and two metastasized but there were no deaths in the period of
follow up.
Malignant Epithelioid Schwannoma (MES) is usually S100 protein
positive, if there is good schwannian differentiation. Superficial
examples of these tumors are sometimes difficult to distinguish
from melanomas but they lack HMB45 (as do some melanomas). Also,
some clear cell sarcomas of tendons and aponeuroses have ultrastructural
features of nerve sheath differentiation.
Divergent Differentiation Tumors with nerve sheath and skeletal
muscle differentiation include: neuromuscular hamartoma, medulloblastoma
with rhabdomyosarcoma, rhabdomyosarcoma with ganglion cells (ectomesenchymoma),
and malignant schwannoma with rhabdomyosarcoma (malignant Triton
tumor). In the latter, rhabdomyoblasts are scattered through the
schwannomatous background. They are usually spindled or rounded
and relatively mature, with eosinophilic cytoplasm, and perhaps
cross-striations Muscle markers are positive and S100 usually
so and EM shows features of both cell types. Glandular malignant
schwannoma has a spindled background and may have other heterotopic
elements such as cartilage or osteoid. The glands are well differentiated
nonciliated cuboidal or columnar cells with clear cytoplasm, occasional
goblets, and neuroendocrine cell differentiation (demonstrable
by chromogranin, etc) (Christensen et al, 1988; Woodruff &
Christensen 1993). Mucin is demonstrable and there is ultrastructural
evidence of intestinal differentiation. Occasionally there are
malignant looking glands. EM of the spindle cells can assist diagnosis
from S100 positive biphasic synovial sarcoma.
Differential Diagnosis: The principal differential diagnosis
of MPNST is provided in Tables 1 and 2.
|
TABLE 1 |
|
|
Monoph synovial |
Leiomyosarcoma |
Fibrosarcoma |
MPNST |
|
Nuclei |
Plump, pale, ovoid,
overlapping |
Blunt-ended |
Tapered |
Buckled, wavy |
|
Patterns |
Parallel, alternating, nodules |
Criss cross,
90 degrees |
Parallel, herringbone |
Alternating, neuroid whorls, subintimal
spread |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Immunohistochemistry |
|
SMA / MSA |
A few |
Yes |
Focal |
Rarely |
|
Desmin |
No |
Yes |
No |
Rarely (& Triton) |
|
S100 protein |
30% |
Some |
No |
60% |
|
Cytokeratins |
Yes |
Some |
No |
Very rarely |
|
EMA |
Yes |
Some |
No |
Very rarely |
|
CD34 |
No |
Some |
No |
Some |
|
bcl2 |
All |
No |
No |
Some |
|
TABLE 2 |
|
Tumor type |
EM features |
|
MPNST |
Interdigitating processes, lamina, mesaxons,
long-spaced collagen |
|
Synovial sarcoma (mono) |
Short processes in intercellular spaces,
junctions |
|
Leiomyosarcoma |
External lamina, pinocytosis, myofilaments,
attachment plaques |
|
Fibrosarcoma |
Abundant ER, Golgi, no lamina or junctionns |
|
Myofibrosarcoma |
RER, Myofilaments, fragmented lamina,
fibonexus |
